Welcome to Netrider ... Connecting Riders!

Interested in talking motorbikes with a terrific community of riders?
Signup (it's quick and free) to join the discussions and access the full suite of tools and information that Netrider has to offer.

Understanding Brake Pad ratings

Discussion in 'Technical and Troubleshooting Torque' at netrider.net.au started by robsalvv, Feb 1, 2008.

  1. With props to: http://www.ducatigarage.netfirms.com/brakepads.html this is the low down on understanding brake pads and their ratings.



    Disc Brake Pads - Construction, Selection and Break-In

    Most of you will have to replace your bike's brake pads at least once during your lifetime -- unless your idea of riding is pushing your bike back-and-forth in your living room, Flintstone-style.

    As you wander into your local dealer or thumb through the pages of your favorite catalog, you'll find many different brake pad manufacturers, such as Ferodo, DP, Galfer, and EBC. The problem is selecting which pad best suits your riding style and conditions. Other than the a few lines of marketing blurb on the back of their packaging, there's not a lot of information available on how to differentiate pads from one another.



    Luckily your Ducati Garage Editor rounded up heaps of technical information on brake pad construction and testing, so here is the condensed version.


    Construction

    Your brake pads started life in the hands of a friction material formulator, most likely a chemist by degree. Chemists select the composition of a brake pad by choosing from a fixed list of compounds that fall into 4 categories.

    Fibers, such as fiberglass, kevlar, arimid, stainless steel, and aluminum maintain the heat stability of the pad. These fibers have various binding strengths and can be organic or metallic. Friction Modifiers such as graphite adjust the friction level and fine tune the performance characteristics of the pad at specific cold and hot temperatures. Fillers take up dead space in the pad. These are generally organic materials with some low frictional effect such as sawdust. Finally, Resins are used to hold the elements of the pad together so they don't crumble apart.

    Every motorcycle disc brake pad that I've ever seen has been manufactured using an Integral Molding (IM) process. Bascially, the pad formulation (sort of like a cake mix) is pressed in a mold against the steel backing plate using adhesives and mechanical locking.

    Most high performance pads are positive molded. This means that only one pad is pressed in the mold at a time. Some pad manufacturers who use mass production equipment will flash mold their pads. This means that the mold creates a whole tray of pads, all pressed at the same time. In general a positive mold pad is more durable and has a high sheer strength because the full force of the manufacturing press is applied to one pad at a time. If you're unsure of what method your favorite brake pad manufacture uses, ASK THEM.

    After the pad has been molded is molded into a puck and bonded to the steel backing plate, it is usually cured in an industrial oven to slowly remove the moisture that remains in the pad compound. Without this slow curing step, your pad would basically be "rapid cured" the first time you applied your brakes. The problem with that is the rapidly escaping moisture would seek an immediate escape route out of the pad compound, creating small fissures that would lead shortly to cracking and chunking.

    Finally, the steel backing plate of the pad is painted and a series of edge codes are printed on the back of the pad.

    The edge codes are the seemingly random combination of letters and numbers that appear on the back of the pad. These codes usually refer back to the registered friction formulation, and more importantly, show a consumer how the pad ranked in a Chase Test.


    The Chase Test

    If you've barely stayed awake reading the previous paragraphs, then grab a cup of java and read on because here's where the good stuff is!

    The Chase Test, better known as the SAE J866A test procedure, provides a uniform means of identification that may be used to describe the initial frictional characteristic of any brake lining.

    The Chase Test is used to assign a two character code (e.g. EE, FF, GG, HH, etc) to a specific friction formulation. These characters represent the coefficient of friction when a 1" square piece of friction material is subjected to varying conditions of load, temperature, pressure and rubbing speed on a test apparatus known as the Chase machine.

    The coefficient of friction measured by the Chase test describes the relationship between the two forces acting on the friction material. A clamping force is exerted on the friction material, resulting in a frictional or resistance force. A low coefficient of friction means that very little of the clamping force is transferred into resistance force. On the other hand, a high coefficient of friction means that given the same level of clamping force, a higher resistance force is generated by the brake pad.

    For example, a pad that carries an HH code has a normal coefficient of friction of 0.55 or higher, and a hot coefficient of friction of 0.55 or higher.

    The first letter of the code represents the normal friction coefficient. This is defined as the the average of four test data points measured at 200, 250, 300 and 400 degrees Farenheit.

    The second letter of the code represents the hot friction coefficient based on a fade and recovery test. We all should know what brake fade is. If you've ever had to use the front brake extensively and found that its effectiveness quickly diminished, that's fade. Recovery is basically the period where the brakes are gradually cooling off.

    The hot friction coefficient is defined as the average of 10 data points located at 400 and 300F. on the first recovery cycle of the pad; 450, 500, 550, 600 and 650F. on the second fade cycle; and 500, 400, and 300F on the second recovery cycle.

    The range of friction coefficients assigned to each code letter are as follows: C = less than 0.15. D= 0.15 to 0.25. E= 0.25 to 0.35. F= 0.35 to 0.45. G= 0.45 to 0.55, and H= over 0.55.

    If H is the highest coefficient of friction, then why aren't all pads manufactured and rated to a HH specification? Well, while a HH pad might be ideal for high performance or track day riding, it could be too "grabby" or aggressive for those of you who spend your time commuting. Similarly, some "racing" brake pads are unsuitable for the casual Sunday canyon ride because they never reach their ideal operating temperature, much like racing tires, in these relatively gentle conditions.

    So how do you select the right set of pads for your bike? This may seem silly but just contact the manufacturer and ask them for a little advice. With your newfound knowledge on brake pad construction plus an honest assessment of your riding style and conditions, any qualified brake technician should be able to steer you in the right direction. If you can't decide between brands, try asking other Duc riders on the Ducati Index "Help Needed" message board. If no one else on the board has heard of the brand you've selected, you may not want to be the guinea pig for an unknown product.

    Of the brands mentioned in this story, I've personally used DP and EBC products in the past and have been happy with their performance and wear characteristics. My riding conditions are weekend canyon rides and an occasional open track day, so the street compounds from both companies worked fine for me.


    Disc Pad Installation and Break-In

    Here's a quick plug for proper maintenance of your brake system. Bleed you brakes as frequently as you can (at least once per year.) Thoroughly clean the brake caliper, dust seals, guide pins, etc with a can of automotive brake clean solution after removing your old pads. On higher mileage bikes, remember to use a micrometer to measure the thickness of your rotors. You may think a set of new pads are all you need, but your rotors might just be one ride away from the junk bin.

    Once you've decided on an appropriate disc brake pad for your riding style and have them installed on your bike, you'll want to bed the pads in by making a series of gentle, controlled stops from a speed of 40-50mph. Find a nice open stretch of road. The first few stops may seem a little scary as you squeeze the brakes and get poor stopping results. Don't be alarmed. This is merely the result of the last amounts of residual moisture and adhesives working their way out of the pad and into the atmosphere. After a few more controlled stops, you should feel a dramatic increase in braking effectiveness.

    Resist the urge to immediately go out and hammer on the brakes with high speed, tire smoking stops. This will likely lead to pad glazing, a condition where the resins in the pad crystalize on the friction surface, resulting in poor stopping performance and excessive noise. If this occurs, the pads are useless. Throw them away, buy another set and start the whole process over again.





    [​IMG]
    Above: Here's a rather unexciting picture of a backing plate on a set of DP pads. The Chase code is shown on the second line, marked "HH." Also note the holes in the backing plate. This is where the friction material was pressed into the holes during the molding process, creating a mechanical bond and increasing the sheer strength of the friction puck.
     
     Top
    • Informative Informative x 2
    • Like Like x 1
  2. now this thread takes me back to engineering science in 1997, where the subject for my studies were "Bicycles Brakes and Lawnmowers".
    We had to chose one of the above for our major piece, and because i had a contact at Bendix, i chose brakes.
    ahhh, the nostalgia!

    good thread :applause:
     
     Top
  3. Take glazed pads, and run them in a couple of figure-of-eight motions over finely grained concrete. They'll require a couple of stops to bed in again, but will be as good as new from my experience.

    I was interested to have an actual feel for the Chase rating, but for the life of me can't read the codes on my pads. The street pads I tried running felt rubbish, and the race pads only last 3 to 4 races @ $120 a pop. Rock and a hard place.
     
     Top
  4. Thanks Joel :)

    I've been thinking about brakes lately and a better understanding of brake pad materials seemed to be a hole in all the threads about braking in NR. So I did some looking around.

    The Ducati site had the best discussion on the topic - and it's now part of NR just incase their page ever goes down.



    Devo, I came across several sites that detailed different bedding down techniques for different brand pads. The wrong technique can leave your pad unsuitable or unlikely to perform as expected. It'd be worth talking to the manufacturer of your preferred brake pads.

    For racing you'd be using HH pads wouldn't you? The article above is circa 2001, so may not be current for the kevlar style brakes available now. Maybe the kevlar style racing brakes don't fit into the chase rating????
     
     Top
  5. I haven't glazed any since I upgraded brakes (for the second time :roll: ), and it wasn't from bedding in, just cooking them in general.

    As for the my current setup I'm entirely clueless. As far as I know there's only two types of pads from only one manufacturer for my caliper, so I just tried them both and ran with it. I'm interested just for curiosity's sake though.
     
     Top
  6. Great info rob.

    Can we make this a sticky please?
     
     Top
  7. Yep :)
     
     Top
  8. Oh! :shock: I'm all sticky! :LOL:

    :cool:

    Glad to have posted up something seen as being of value. :)
     
     Top
  9. I am running a carbon metallic pad for the SV from this mob http://www.performancefriction.com/pages/cycles.htm

    I will let you know the results next week. My bedding in procedure is a bit more detailed than yours and I've got to get the pads hot before they work well :?
     
     Top
  10. :?
    that goes against everything i studied, i wonder what the deal is there? perhaps the expansion of the metallic content in the pad itself? *shrug*
     
     Top
  11. They are a heavy carbon compund pad. The running in process is designed to leave a small amount of carbon residue on the rotor. The intent is then that the pad becomes a carbon-carbon mating surface.

    One thing that Rob didn't mention is that braking performance falls of markedly (under heavy load) when the pads get beyond half their wear. I discovered this with the OEM pads on the SV. Once they get half worn, a lot of pad material has gone walkabout leaving very little left to disperse the heat. They then get very hot, very quickly, causing binding and other materials to boil. Apparently (and I only have this 3rd hand) this is the glazing that you can see on heavy use worn pads.
     
     Top
  12. That's pretty common with race pads on both cars and bikes.
     
     Top
  13. ok, so my understanding is that;
    compounds that provide a greater coefficient of friction (less pressure at the lever) generally fade, or the coefficient is reduced as temperature increases.
    compounds that provide a more consistent coefficient of friction across the temperature range require more pressure at the lever, but this will not change (as much) as they heat up.
    so, could i be so bold as to suggest that it is the rotor that heats up, causing expansion, therefore requiring less range in the lever to activate the brake as opposed to the friction compound in the pad heating up and becoming more, "frictiony"?
    i just had a quick squizz through the compound that is used in the carbon metallic, and the thing that jumped out straight away was the absence of fillers, particularly clay and similar.
    remember, it's been a loooong time since i pondered this stuff and i am just a roadworker after all..... :)
     
     Top
  14. What are the fillers and how would they affect performance? This from an IT professional....
     
     Top
  15. kinda like making a sausage.
    we all know there is meat (friction material) in a sausage, but there is also breadcrumbs etc. (fillers) that possibly dont adversely affect the flavour (stopping ability) but make the item cheaper to produce.

    clay is a common filler used to "bulk up" the friction material because it is cheap, has a relatively good coefficient of friction, is negatively charged, and doesnt produce lethal toxins as it heats up/wears.
    i understand that this is where the term pad "glazing" came from in the early days, as the clay content would be high, and the high temperatures it was exosed to would actually glaze the clay compnent as though it were in a kiln.
     
     Top
  16. Thanks for a great read Rob.

    Oh, and I just found out that they've got an even higher rated brake pad for use solely on pirate ships. They call it I.I.





    ...get it?




    ....WAAAAAAAAA I kill me.
     
     Top
  17. Joel, I would say with some certainty that it has nothing to do with the expansion of the disc and decreased range at the lever.

    Looking at it logically, but with no specific knowledge on brake pads, it still makes sense. Whether it's abrasive or cohesive friction, both require bonds to be broken / formed and broken. Depending on the chemical compounds used, the optimum operating temperature is set by the conditions under which the frictional materials begin to break down chemically. This could just as easily be 50 degrees, as it could be 550 degrees, but the chemists would work to the application. The idea that pads reduce in effectiveness as temperature increases is missing one step. They increase in effectiveness, then decrease.
     
     Top
  18. cool answer, makes sense :cool:
     
     Top
  19. Rob to also add to this when doing the bed in process one should not bring the vehicle to a complete stop either.
     
     Top
  20. Great Post Rob !
    As a coincidence I was just doing some homework myself, as I am about to replace pads on the H6. Was looking at some EBC HH pads.

    Thanks, was very informative!
     
     Top